Spoštovani,

Mislimo, da naše včerajšnje obvestilo javnosti vsebuje dovolj jasne javnosti dostopne podatke, trende in rezultate iskanj v daljšem obdobju največje pozornosti javnosti. Jasno kažejo, da ni neke razumne, logične razlage in argumenta za padec iz 13.104 zadetkov na 10.367 med 16.12.10 in 23.1210, ko smo imeli zelo odmevno vabilo in tiskovno konferenco, izključno na Najdi.si, ter od takrat dalje zelo počasno rast. In to v obdobju največje in strme rasti strani, ki poročajo o nas. Pričakovan rezultat bi bil okrog 20.000 zadetkov in nadaljnja strma rast dalje. To so vprašanja, ki zahtevajo odgovor zakaj se je to zgodilo?

Glede na reakcije je bilo jasno, da če ne vključimo javnosti ne bomo hitro dobili jasnih odgovorov, če sploh kdaj. Reakcije najverjetneje kažejo na zavlačevanje z odgovorom, da zamre interes javnosti za to zadevo. Javnost ima pravico vedeti in biti seznanjena z vsemi nepravilnostmi, posebej, če se gre za tako občutljivo zadevo, kot so svoboda obveščanja javnosti, svoboda izražanja, dostop do dejstev in resnice, skrivni dokumenti in WikiLeaks.si.

Google.si iskanje zadetkov samo v slovenskem jeziku: 21,700: http://www.google.si/search?q=%22wikileaks+si%22&hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&num=10&lr=lang_sl&ft=i&cr=&safe=images&tbs=

Tukaj so očitna in prevelika odstopanja med Googlom in Najdi.si. Poudarim naj, da smo zgolj postavili vprašanje na osnovi nam in javnosti znanih dejstev. Na osnovi do sedaj znanih podatkov vsak normalen človek vidi in sklepa, da to najverjetneje kaže, da tukaj nekaj ne »štima« in se vpraša ali Najdi.si cenzurira WikiLeaks.si? Ne trdimo, da je Najdi.si priredil rezultate iskanja. To naj ugotovijo neodvisni računalniški strokovnjaki, novinarji, vse odgovorne inštitucije, ki so zavezane k temu, če treba tudi neodvisna parlamentarna komisija. Upam, da bodo čim prej ukrepale in razjasnile zadeve.

Vse skupaj je zelo enostavno razjasniti. Dajte nam, javnosti in neodvisnim strokovnjakom takoj na razpolago vse loge in statistike v decembru 2010, ki se nanašajo na »WikiLeaks.si«. V primeru, da se izkaže, da so to originalne, ne prirejene datoteke, da obstaja kreditibilna in argumentirana razlaga zakaj je prišlo do tega, sem se pripravljen opravičiti.

Primož Vallant

Ustanovitelj in predstavnik

Dear all,

We believe that the press release we made yesterday includes clear and publicly accessible facts, trends and search results covering a large period of high public interest. It clearly shows that there is no logical, reasonable explanation for the sudden fall, exclusively on Najdi.si, from 13.104 to 10.367 hits, between 16/12/2010 to 23/12/2010, the period of the invitation to and the actual high-profile press conference on Wikileaks.si. Since then, we have witnessed very slow growth in a period of high and rapid increase of pages reporting on us. The expected result would be 20.000 hits and growing. Our question demands an answer – why the decline in hits? If you had made an effort to give exact answers, you would have done it already. I personally made two unsuccessful attempts to get an answer from you by telephone. Computer experts know that very exact statistics and results are only a few clicks away – a matter of minutes.

Considering your reaction, it is obvious that we will get results only if we include the public media in our quest for a clear answer. The reaction most probably points to procrastination until the public interest around this topic dies down. The public has the right to be informed about any incorrectness, especially concerning such sensitive matters as freedom of the press, freedom of expression, access to facts and truth, secret documents and Wikileaks.si.

Until now, we checked the Najdi.si search results on Google.si. But because the results on Google.si include results from other countries (and have a much wider range), we yesterday deliberately verified the search results both on Google.si and Google.com for pages in Slovenian only, in order to arrive at a credible comparison. Here are the actual results:

Google.si - hit search in Slovenian: 21.700: http://www.google.si/search?q=%22wikileaks+si%22&hl=en&client=firefox-a&rls=org.mozilla%3Aen-US%3Aofficial&num=10&lr=lang_sl&ft=i&cr=&safe=images&tbs=

Google.com – hit search in Slovenian: 21.600: : http://www.google.com/search?q=%22wikileaks+si%22&hl=en&num=10&lr=lang_sl&ft=i&cr=&safe=images&tbs=#sclient=psy&hl=en&lr=lang_sl&tbs=lr:lang_1sl&source=hp&q=%22wikileaks+si%22&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&oq=%22wikileaks+si%22&gs_rfai=&pbx=1&fp=ec8755212bd36d2b

There is an obvious and wide deviation between Google and Najdi,si. I reassert that we studied the question on the basis of publicly available information. On the basis of the actual publicly available intelligence every normal person concludes that something here is not “right”, and wonders if Najdi.si censors Wikileaks.si.
Let this matter be explored by independent computer experts, journalists, accountable institutions and if need be, an independent parliamentary commission. My hope is that they will act promptly to clarify this matter.

It is interesting to note that each time that suspected irregularities are discovered – which in most cases prove based on fact – the whistle-blower is blamed and threatened.

It is very simple to clarify this by making available to the public and to independent experts all the logs and statistics from December 2010, referring to Wikileaks.si. In the verified case that they are original, unadulterated databases and that there is a credible explanation for the discrepancies, I am ready to apologise.

Otherwise, I will be in Ljubljana on Monday and am willing to visit you in the company of journalists in order to clarify this business – although we cannot arrive at a final opinion without the expertise of an independent computer specialist.

Please forward this message or this link to all interested parties:
http://www.vallant.si/press-room/sporocila-javnosti/odgovor-vallant-si-na-izmikajnje-najdi-si-glede-wikileaks-si-in-groznjo-s-tozbo.

Regards,

Primož Vallant

Founder and representative

Non-for-profit Foundation Vallant.si (in the process of establishing); Wikileaks.si; Civil initiative for the protection of rule of law, welfare state & nature.

If you would like to enter on our list of recipients of press releases, please click on this link <mailto:info@vallant.biz?subject=PRIJAVA%20OBVESTIL%20MEDIJEM> and send created message.

If you would like to leave our list of recipients of press releases, please click on this link <mailto:info@vallant.biz?subject=ODJAVA%20OBVESTIL%20MEDIJEM> and send created message.